Originally posted by sunshine
I have to agree with Zelda and Manda all the way I love Sarah Brightmans voice she sings each note Beautifuly and to its fullest. Emmy looked as if she was struggling to sing the high notes like in think of me, but Sarah just let the music flow right out of her. Emmy was ok but for the most part she almost looked as if she were lip singing, I didnt like her voice at all. Sarah B. is and always will be Christine for me. :D
Well, she is lipsynching (sp?) during the movie. They had to record it before and then they sang quietly during the recording of the movie itself. The recording of their voices was put over the quiet ones. Everyone in the movie is lipsynching. But it is their voice except for Carlotta (Minnie Driver).
And as for my opinion, I like both Emmy's and Sarah's voices but I'm drawn more toward Emmy. I think she did a brilliant job!